It all started with Syracuse University.
I came across an article stating Syracuse had a problem: fewer students were showing up. The university missed its enrollment target, faces a budget deficit, and has already pruned academic programs.
The first suspects I imagined included soaring tuition putting college financially out of reach, young people questioning whether a degree is worth it, and a new biggie: international students having a new – ahem, Administrative – reason to reconsider America.
All plausible. But then I ran into another factor with the data to back it up: there are simply fewer eighteen-year-olds. Demographers have been watching this particular train coming for years.
Where have I been?
American high-school graduates peaked at 3.9 million in 2025, and are projected to decline about 13 percent by 2041. The reason is straightforward: birth rates fell after the Great Recession began in 2008, resulting in a smaller generation now reaching college age. So, some of those missing Syracuse students are not just choosing another school – God forbid, Pittsburgh. No, they were simply never in the pipeline.
And that’s where the question changed. Syracuse wasn’t really the story. It was just where the larger one first popped up on my radar. Demography moves slowly enough that you can see it coming long off. Yet institutions are still surprised when it arrives.
Japan has been living through its version for decades, and I feared this turn could get grim. Japan has the world’s oldest population for a major country, around 30%. Next up, tiny Monaco, where a whopping 36% of the population qualify for a senior-discount.
But back to Japan. Its workforce has been shrinking over decades, and employers struggle to find workers. Hundreds of schools close every year – really, hundreds. And every year for 30 years, not just recently. Rural towns are emptying out. They even have a word for all the vacant houses: akiya. There it was, I thought. The cautionary tale. Have babies or become Japan.
Except Japan doesn’t behave like a cautionary tale. It remains rich, orderly and technologically sophisticated. The population is not roaming graffiti-strewn Tokyo neighborhoods fighting over scarce stir-fry.
The country has been adapting. More women work. More older people work. Companies automate what they can. They use a lot of vending machines. And despite historically restrictive immigration policies, the country has quietly opened some jobs to foreign workers.
Meanwhile, communities confront the uncomfortable decisions about which schools, hospitals and train stops still make sense when fewer people are around to use them. This sounds more like an empty-nester renovation than social collapse. Downsizing. And that’s when I started wondering whether I had the problem backwards.
We talk about falling birthrates as though people are going the way of the dodo bird. They aren’t. There are more than eight billion of us. What is disappearing, in countries like Japan, South Korea and much of Europe, is something more specific: constant population growth.
And that’s a different issue. All our institutions really, were built assuming another, larger generation would always be coming behind us. So universities built acres of dormitories and companies counted on expanding markets and labor forces.
Governments established retirement programs that make perfect sense with an incrementally larger workforce each year. Demographically, it looks an awful lot like a pyramid. You know, scheme.
But now the pyramid is turning into a column. And “suddenly,” Syracuse has too many open seats. But don’t defrost those eggs just yet. The United States is not Japan. We have one major difference: immigration.
The Congressional Budget Office projects that American deaths will begin exceeding births in 2030. 2030? It’s not too early to plan a 2030 summer vacation. But without immigration, that’s when the U.S. population begins shrinking, while I’m maybe on a cruise. With immigration, the CBO projects continued growth until about 2056.
Whatever anyone thinks the “proper” level of immigration should be, American immigrants are hardly just additional mouths to feed in an already crowded country. The majority tend to be younger, driven, working-age people entering a country that is getting older and producing fewer workers of its own.
Which brings us back to babies. Governments have tried all sorts of things to persuade people to have more of them. Checks. Tax breaks. Childcare subsidies. Parental leave. Campaigns selling the joys of family life. Some of the policies make raising children less punishing – worthwhile on its own. But there’s an inconvenient snag in the grand national baby plans. They can’t solve any immediate labor problems.
A child born this morning will not solve next year’s nursing shortage. For a while, that child actually creates more work and consumes more resources. The replacement employee we’re after starts applying for jobs around 2045. Will I even be alive then? That was the point where my original question – How to fix the falling birthrate? – stopped seeming quite right.
Maybe a more useful question is: Can we adapt our society to not require an ever-larger next generation to keep the machinery running? Maybe we need to rethink the very concept of growth as the ideal. They tell us the iron rule of business is: companies that don’t grow, die.
But if an economy can no longer count on an expanding population of workers and consumers, how do we measure progress? What does a successful economy look like when getting bigger is no longer attainable? It may mean reconsidering what an economy is for in the first place, what it should do for us.
The machinery’s purpose should serve the people living in it. For generations, we’ve treated extracting more, producing more, selling more and throwing more away as evidence that the system is working. The result is monopolized corporate control of labor, extracting and hoarding vast wealth. For the majority though, the people making the machine work, their buying-power has hardly changed in 50 years. And on a crowded, warming planet, we’re discovering some other serious design flaws.
A tack could be organizing our economy around sustainability, durability, reuse, public well-being and getting greater value from fewer resources. A richer life doesn’t require an ever-growing pile of stuff and trash. Success can be measured in other ways than corporate profit.
Of course, fewer workers supporting more retirees is a real financial problem. Nursing homes need staff and pensions need funding. That doesn’t disappear when we decide growth is overrated. But consider the peculiar bargain behind much of the national anxiety over declining birthrates: have more children today so tomorrow’s institutions can continue operating much as they always have.
See what that got us.
I went looking for a baby shortage and found modern society built on a faltering pyramid scheme, now aware the next pool of marks is running dry.